CompropScotland Logo01:11, Saturday, July 04, 2009
The online Commercial Property Newspaper for Scotland


new house box

Edinburgh office landlord scores tram rates victory

By JIM DOW

A LANDMARK decision could see a business rate reduction of five per cent for hundreds of offices on the route of the Edinburgh tram line, which is currently under construction.

An appeal by GVA Grimley, acting for a client based on Shandwick Place, successfully argued that offices on the route – which also takes in Leith Walk, Princes Street and St. Andrew Square – faced a general level of disruption.

Shandwick Place was closed to traffic in March 2008 before being reopened in July of the same year. Work is expected to restart this autumn, but the Lothian Assessors Department had previously maintained only retail properties and the like should benefit from any relief.

Gordon Martin, business rates associate at GVA Grimley, said: “The Assessor insisted shops, restaurants and pubs in the area were the only properties facing tangible disruption and awarded them a 20 per cent cut in rates.

A montage of trams operating on Shandwick Place
A montage of trams operating on Shandwick Place

“However, a number of upper floor offices with entrances on the same stretches of road, including that of our client, are affected by noise pollution, dust, restricted access and other disturbances associated with major works.

“We were able to persuade the valuation appeal committee an allowance was also appropriate in this case."

Mr Martin added: “Naturally, we would have welcomed higher cuts, but are pleased the committee has ruled in our client’s favour.”

GVA issued a press release hailing the “ground-breaking decision” but when I tried to obtain more information I was told that no more could be provided.

It seems that the assessor was unhappy with a press release being issued, perhaps realising the far-reaching effect of the decision and mindful of the fact that there can be an appeal by 12 February .

This led to welcoming words from Roy Durie of Ryden. “They have now created a precedent,” he said.


'Green shoot' on George Street

By Stewart McIntosh

While it is too early to declare a thaw in the market, an £8.7 million deal on Edinburgh’s George Street could indicate a slight cracking in commercial property’s nuclear winter.

In one of the first investment deals of 2009, Scottish Widows Investment Partnership has sold George House at 126/128 George Street on behalf of clients. The purchaser was Edinburgh-based Thistle Property Group and the price reflects a net initial yield of 7.25 per cent.

Behind its listed façade, which dates back to 1785, the accommodation comprises 18,500 sq ft of modern open plan office space, plus a leisure or retail unit on the ground floor.

Marketing agent Alasdair Humphery of Jones Lang LaSalle said: “Despite a challenging marketing environment we generated very credible interest from the UK, Ireland and overseas. This sale demonstrates that quality product is still sought after by a broad cross section of the market.”

Elliot Cassels, a partner a Montagu Evans in Edinburgh who acted on behalf of Thistle

Property Group said: “We are delighted to have secured this prime property for our client, with income secured to the Scottish Ministers and Scottish and Newcastle.”

Alasdair McCaig of Thistle Property Group argues that “sensibly priced” commercial property investments are beginning to come onto the market. “The recent reduction in borrowing costs means buying prime assets at a sensible yield works well for us – and the acquisition of George House fits in well with our existing portfolio,” he said.

Meanwhile, Infrastructure Management Ltd has taken 4,909 sq ft at 11 Thistle Street, Edinburgh, at a rent of £19 a sq ft. The company, which provides vehicle management services, has struck a 10-year deal, with a 5-year lease break. The landlord is Zurich Assurance Limited, for whom JLL and DTZ are letting agents.

And in Glasgow, G1 – the former GPO HQ in George Square – has secured its first tenant at a new headline rental for the city.

Gardiner & Theobold has signed a deal to occupy the 12,314 sq ft first floor of the HF Developments scje,e and will move into the 131,000 sq ft building when it is completed later this year.

Announcement from Comprop

Following this issue, CompropScotland will be going offline for a while.

With more than two million hits per annum, we believe we’ve created a journalistic success and have set new standards in the coverage of commercial property north of the border.

However, our business model relies on advertising and sponsorship to deliver the income flow required to write and edit a quality, free to access, online newspaper. Therefore, while Comprop does not have any debt and has actually produced a net profit since its launch in September 2006, the level of business support from the commercial property community has been insufficient to justify the time and effort involved in maintaining our level of editorial output. Having said that, we’d like to express our sincere thanks for the remarkable loyalty of a small group of advertisers and sponsors.

We’re now taking some time out to investigate alternative business models for Comprop and to explore opportunities in other business sectors. Meanwhile, we’d welcome any feedback or suggestions from our readers. We hope to be back.

Next >>
advert
CompropScotland FooterCompropScotland Footer